GTLA.ORG
  • About
    • President's Message
    • Leadership
      • Executive Committee
      • Vice Presidents
      • Past Presidents
    • Staff
    • Committees
    • Local TLAs
    • Constitution & By-laws
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Members
    • Join GTLA
    • Membership Renewal
    • Update Member Profile
    • Listserve
      • About GTLA Lists
      • Browse Messages
      • Search Messages
      • Post Messages On-line
      • Manage List Settings
    • Upcoming Events
    • Research Tools
      • Expert Depositions
      • Expert Challenges
      • Briefs & Motions
      • Legal Forms
      • Experts for Hire
      • Fastcase Law Library
      • How to Upload Documents
    • CLE
      • CLE Calendar
      • CLE Webinars
      • CLE Bookstore
      • Check Your CLE
      • Champion Materials
    • Request Amicus Briefs
    • Job Bank
    • Trial Case Calendar
      • View Members' Trials
      • Submit Your Trial to Calendar
  • Legislative
    • Meet the Team
    • Legislative Issues & Talking Points
    • Legislative Watch
    • Lawyer of the Day
      • About Lawyer of the Day
      • Sign Up
    • 2013 Final Report
    • Capitol Impact
    • Legislative Resources
      • Who Are My Elected Officials
      • The Georgia General Assembly
      • How a Bill Becomes Law
  • Press Room
    • Press Releases & Articles
    • GTLA Publications
        • The Verdict Magazine
        • In the Know Newsletter
      • GTLA Blogroll
  • For the Public
    • Who We Are
    • 7th Amendment Scholarship
    • Find an Attorney
    • Speakers Bureau
    • American Association for Justice
    • Civil Justice Facts & Talking Points
      • Your Right to Trial by Jury
      • Contingency Fees
      • Mythbusters
      • Tort Reform Response Kit
      • Medical Malpractice Facts
      • The Facts on GA's Tort Reform
      • The Truth Behind Hot Coffee
    • Cases that Made a Difference
  • Sponsors
    • Publication Rates and Dates
    • Events & Exhibitor Info
    • Preferred Partners
  • PAC
    • Contribute
    • About the PAC
    • Board of Directors
 
(404) 522-8487           
  Login
    • About
      • President's Message
      • Leadership
        • Executive Committee
        • Vice Presidents
        • Past Presidents
      • Staff
      • Local TLAs
      • Constitution & By-laws
      • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Members
      • Join GTLA
      • Membership Renewal
      • Update Member Profile
      • GTLA Member Directory
      • Listserve
        • About GTLA Lists
        • Browse Messages
        • Search Messages
        • Post Messages On-line
        • Manage List Settings
      • Upcoming Events
      • Research Tools
        • Expert Depositions
        • Expert Challenges
        • Briefs & Motions
        • Legal Forms
        • Experts for Hire
        • Fastcase Law Library
      • CLE
        • CLE Calendar
        • CLE Webinars
        • CLE Bookstore
        • Check Your CLE
        • Champion Materials
      • Amicus Curiae
        • Request Amicus Briefs
        • Amicus Brief Archives
      • Job Bank
      • Trial Case Calendar
        • View Members' Trials
        • Submit Your Trial to Calendar
    • Legislative
      • Meet the Team
      • Legislative Issues & Talking Points
      • Lawyer of the Day
        • About Lawyer of the Day
      • Legislative Resources
        • Who Are My Elected Officials
        • The Georgia General Assembly
    • Press Room
      • Press Releases & Articles
      • GTLA Publications
        • The Verdict Magazine
        • The Monthly Docket Newsletter
    • For the Public
      • Who We Are
      • Find an Attorney
      • American Association for Justice
      • Civil Justice Facts & Talking Points
        • Your Right to Trial by Jury
        • Contingency Fees
        • Mythbusters
        • Tort Reform Response Kit
        • Medical Malpractice Facts
        • The Facts on GA's Tort Reform
        • The Truth Behind Hot Coffee
      • Cases that Made a Difference
    • Sponsors
      • Publication Rates and Dates
      • Events & Exhibitor Info
      • Justice Partners
    • PAC
      • Contribute
      • About the PAC
      • Board of Directors
Home      Root      MuggerCase  

In This Section

THE MUGGER CASE

The"subway" Version

The Claim:

A convicted felon caught mugging a 71-year-old man became paralyzed after New York Transit police shot him. The jury awarded the felon $4.3 million for his injury.

The Truth:

This version of the case blatantly omits these key facts: In June 1984, Jerome Sanducky was mugged by two young men in a subway station at 96th Street in New York City. In the station at the time was plainclothes police officer Manuel Rodriguez. The officer intervened in the mugging and shot at the two men as they attempted to escape. Two bullets struck Bernard McCummings as he fled down a stairwell, severing his spinal cord and paralyzing him from the waist down.

McCummings pleaded guilty to second-degree attempted robbery and served 32 months in prison. His civil suit against the Transit Authority was filed within a year of the shooting.

At the civil trial in 1990, it was shown that McCummings had been shot after the crime was committed and while he was running away from Rodriguez, in clear violation of the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Tennessee v. Garner that police may not shoot any felon who is fleeing after committing a crime unless there is probable cause to believe that the suspect poses a threat of "serious physical harm" to an officer or bystander. McCummings was unarmed at the time and made no threatening motions toward bystanders or the police.

More importantly, it was revealed that the Transit Authority attempted to cover up the fact that McCummings was shot in the back while fleeing by concocting a false account of events and having officers perpetuate this conspiracy on the witness stand.

After four days of deliberation, the jury awarded McCummings $4.3 million, finding that Officer Rodriguez used excessive force and was not justified in shooting the fleeing mugger. Jurors later admitted that while feeling no sympathy for the felon, there was no way they could believe the ever-growing pile of contradictory statements and lies offered by the police in an attempt to hide Officer Rodriguez's culpability. The jury decision was subsequently upheld by New York's two appellate courts, including its highest court.

Cites: McCummings v. New York City Transit Authority, 613 N.E.2d 559 (N.Y. 1993); "Why a Mugger Won $4.3 Million," The American Lawyer, May 1994, at 68.

 

Georgia Trial Lawyers Association
  • About
  • Members
  • Legislative
  • Press Room
  • Public
  • Sponsors
  • PAC

3350 Centennial Tower
101 Marietta Street
Atlanta, GA 30303

Phone: (404) 522-8487

Fax: (404) 522-3705

About Us

Since 1956, GTLA has worked tirelessly to ensure that everyday citizens, Georgia families and small businesses are never deprived of their constitutional guarantee of access to true justice. The Mission of GTLA is simple:  We are dedicated to protecting the Constitutional promise of justice for all by guaranteeing the right to trial by jury, preserving an independent judiciary, and providing access to the courts for all Georgians.

© 2013. All Rights reserved.